Breaking Down: Analyzing the Colts’ Offensive Position Units After the Draft

Analyzing the Colts’ Offensive Position Groups Post-Draft

With the 2024 NFL Draft now completed, it’s an opportune moment to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the Colts’ roster. Each position group will be evaluated based on its current state, considering factors such as player health and performance. The grading scale ranges from A+ to F, reflecting exceptional to poor conditions, respectively.

Quarterback
Starter: Anthony Richardson
Backup: Joe Flacco
Depth: Sam Ehlinger, Kedon Slovis, Jason Bean

The quarterback unit is in excellent shape. Richardson has shown remarkable progress in his throws during the offseason, demonstrating immense talent despite limited action last season. With Flacco as a reliable backup, the Colts possess a strong tandem. However, Ehlinger’s lackluster performance suggests his time with the team may be coming to an end. Meanwhile, Bean’s exceptional speed adds an intriguing dimension, especially in potential backup roles.

Grade: A

Running Backs
Starter: Jonathan Taylor
Backup: Evan Hull
Depth: Tyler Goodson, Trey Sermon, Zavier Scott

Led by Taylor, one of the premier running backs in the NFL, this group boasts top-tier talent. However, concerns arise regarding depth following the departure of Zack Moss. The effectiveness of Hull as a versatile contributor remains uncertain, impacting the overall grade despite Taylor’s excellence.

Grade: A-

Wide Receivers
Starting Z: Michael Pittman Jr
Starting X: Alec Pierce/Adonai Mitchell
Starting Slot: Josh Downs
Backups: Ashton Dulin, Anthony Gould, DJ Montgomery, Juwann Winfree, Ethan Fernea, Tyrie Cleveland, Terrell Bynum, Xavier White

Pittman and Downs provide solid foundations for the receiving corps. However, uncertainties surround the X receiver position, with Pierce’s inconsistent performance and Mitchell’s unproven status. While the group showcases potential, unresolved questions prevent it from receiving a higher grade.

Grade: A-

Tight Ends
Starter: Jelani Woods
Backup: Kylen Granson
Depth: Mo Alie-Cox, Will Mallory, Drew Ogletree, Eric Tomlinson, Jordan Murray, Trent Pennix

The tight end unit emerges as a weak link in the offense, lacking significant offseason improvements. Woods and Granson offer complementary skills but may not excel as full-time starters. Concerns about depth further diminish the group’s overall grade.

Grade: C-

Offensive Line
This group stands out as the strongest within the offense. All starters performed admirably last season and are poised for further success under Shane Steichen’s guidance. Raimann, Nelson, Kelly, Fries, and Smith form a formidable front line. Additionally, the depth received a boost with versatile rookies Goncalves and Bortolino, enhancing the overall strength of the unit.

Grade: A

Overall Grade: A-
The Colts’ offense presents a balanced mix of young talent and experienced veterans, supported by solid long-term and rookie contracts.