Ranking the 10 Greatest Colorado Buffaloes Football Players of All Time

Colorado football boasts a rich history of exceptional athletes who have left an indelible mark on the program. Since the team’s inception in 1890, the Buffaloes have claimed 26 conference titles and a national championship while producing 30 consensus All-Americans and one Heisman Trophy winner.

Colorado football’s legacy is defined by these extraordinary athletes whose talents elevated the program to national prominence. From Rashaan Salaam’s unforgettable Heisman season to Byron White’s unmatched versatility, each of these players left an enduring legacy in Boulder.

Here’s a rundown of the top 10 players who have defined Colorado football over the decades.

10. Kordell Stewart

Kordell Stewart earns his spot at #10 as a standout quarterback for the Buffaloes. While he never achieved All-American status, he came close, securing a second-team selection and earning first-team All-Conference honors. Stewart also shone as the Fiesta Bowl MVP during his time in Boulder. By the end of his college career, he held the top spot on Colorado’s all-time passing yards list, a testament to his lasting legacy, even as others have since surpassed him.

9. Eric Bieniemy

Eric Bieniemy, one of the greatest running backs in Buffaloes history, claims the #9 spot. Bieniemy’s 3,940 career rushing yards remain a school record. A consensus All-American, Bieniemy also contended for the Heisman Trophy. His record-breaking performances remain a high bar for any Colorado rusher to meet.

8. Cliff Branch

At #8, Cliff Branch dazzled as a kick returner and wide receiver after transferring from JUCO. Known for his electrifying speed, Branch amassed eight kick and punt return touchdowns during his two seasons with the Buffaloes. His rare ability to impact games on special teams and as a receiver made him a Colorado legend.

7. Dick Anderson

Safety Dick Anderson earns his place at #7 as a defensive powerhouse. Anderson’s career, highlighted by All-American and first-team All-Conference honors, was defined by his knack for creating turnovers. His 14 career interceptions solidify his status as one of the best defensive players in program history.

6. Darian Hagan

Darian Hagan, the quarterback behind Colorado’s 1990 national championship, takes the #6 spot. A dual-threat QB, Hagan was equally effective as a passer and rusher, amassing 54 total touchdowns during his career. His versatility and leadership were instrumental in the Buffaloes’ championship success.

5. Alfred Williams

Linebacker Alfred Williams ranks as Colorado’s top defensive player at #5. A cornerstone of the 1990 title-winning team, Williams earned All-American honors and won the prestigious Butkus Award. Twice named Big Eight Defensive Player of the Year, he remains one of the most celebrated defenders in school history.

4. Bobby Anderson

Bobby Anderson, the versatile brother of Dick Anderson, claims the #4 spot. A standout at both quarterback and running back, Anderson earned honorable mention All-American honors as a QB before transitioning to All-American status as a running back. His unique ability to excel at multiple positions set him apart as a Buffaloes legend.

3. Joe Romig

Joe Romig, the finest offensive lineman in Colorado history, comes in at #3. A two-time first-team All-American, Romig excelled at protecting quarterbacks and opening running lanes. While linemen rarely garner the same spotlight as skill players, Romig’s dominance in the trenches was pivotal for the Buffaloes’ success.

2. Byron White

At #2, Byron White is a true Colorado icon. Known for his versatility, White excelled as a running back, kick returner, and defensive player. He was the program’s first All-American and finished second in Heisman voting, cementing his reputation as one of the most well-rounded players in college football history.

1. Rashaan Salaam

Topping the list is Rashaan Salaam, the only Heisman Trophy winner in Colorado history. Salaam’s 1994 season, featuring over 2,000 rushing yards and 24 touchdowns, remains one of the greatest campaigns ever by a running back. In addition to the Heisman, he captured the Doak Walker Award and secured his place as the best player to ever wear a Colorado uniform.