Three players from the Colts who failed to live up to their new contracts

When it comes to free agency, the Colts have performed rather well overall. With deals completed with Grover Stewart, Kenny Moore, Raekwon Davis, Tyquan Lewis, and a few other players, Indianapolis has maybe been the most active team in the NFL when it comes to re-signing players. They were obviously putting more emphasis on their defensive line, sticking with their core players as they try to build on a season that had a lot of promise but was ruined by a season-ending injury to Anthony Richardson. They signed Joe Flacco as well! However, not all Colts players will return to Indianapolis the following season; these three players will not live up to the new contracts they agreed to at the start of March.

Three past Colts players who

won’t adhere to their new agreements
1. QB Minshew Gardner

The Raiders are the ones who should award a career backup $25 million. Following his “Pro Bowl” season in Indianapolis, Minshew made a big money move and is currently playing for his fourth team in six years. Although Minshew was adequate as a long-term replacement for Richardson, it doesn’t seem like the best idea to develop a Las Vegas franchise by giving him 34 starts as a bridge quarterback. potentially loses the position in a competition with current starter Aidan O’Connell during training, but the Raiders are still paying their backup more than $20 million for a two-year contract. There aren’t many outgoing free agents on poor contracts with the Colts, but this one is the most obvious.

each of them.

2. Zack Moss, RB
Moss is expected to be the focal point in Cincinnati following spells in Buffalo and Indianapolis, particularly following the Bengals’ transfer of Joe Mixon to the Texans. Moss signed an eight million dollar, two-year contract with the Bengals, so he should be able to live up to it. However, given how most NFL running backs end their careers, it’s not a certain that Moss will still be in Cincinnati at the end of 2026. Though theoretically he still has a lot of career ahead of him at just 26, the Colts don’t have many options in this category, thus a $8 million running back makes the cut.

Isaiah McKenzie, WR, third
Following the establishment of a

McKenzie arrived in Indianapolis in 2022 and played in just 13 games, making two starts, after having a career-high 42 receptions with the Bills. After four straight seasons with at least one touchdown, McKenzie’s 11 receptions and 82 receiving yards were the lowest totals since his freshman year. Additionally, he failed to find the end zone. Now that he’s with the Giants, he primarily appears to be a special teams player or wide receiver at this stage of his career. That’s about what New York offered him for a one-year contract costing $1.5 million, but even that won’t be worth a second contract in 2025 if he continues to produce at the same level as last year.