The Greatest Buffalo Bandits Players of All Time

The Buffalo Bandits are one of the most storied franchises in National Lacrosse League (NLL) history. Since their establishment in 1992, the team has cultivated a rich tradition of excellence and championship success. Over the years, several standout players have etched their names into the hearts of Bandits fans. Here are five of the greatest players in Buffalo Bandits history, celebrated for their remarkable contributions to the franchise.

1. John Tavares

No conversation about the Bandits’ greatest players is complete without mentioning John Tavares, arguably the most iconic figure in NLL history. Tavares played an astonishing 24 seasons (1992–2015), all with the Bandits, making him synonymous with the team. The league’s all-time leader in goals (815), assists (934), and points (1,749), Tavares defined consistency and excellence. A three-time NLL MVP, he led the Bandits to four championships (1992, 1993, 1996, 2008) and was known for his leadership, vision, and clutch performances. Post-retirement, he continues to shape the team as their head coach, solidifying his legacy as the face of the franchise.

2. Dhane Smith

Nicknamed “The Great Dhane,” Dhane Smith is a modern-day superstar who has redefined offensive productivity in the NLL. Smith set a league record for points in a single season with 137 in 2016, earning him the MVP award. His combination of speed, strength, and lacrosse IQ has made him a nightmare for defenders. Since joining the Bandits in 2013, Smith has consistently been among the league’s top scorers, helping the team remain a perennial contender. His ability to dominate games and lead by example ensures his place among Buffalo’s all-time greats.

3. Rich Kilgour

Rich Kilgour is a name that resonates deeply with Bandits fans. A cornerstone of the franchise’s early success, Kilgour played his entire 18-season career (1992–2009) in Buffalo. Known for his gritty play and leadership, he captained the team for over a decade, leading them to multiple championships. Kilgour’s contributions extended beyond the stat sheet, as he was a relentless competitor and an inspirational figure in the locker room. After retiring, he transitioned to coaching, further solidifying his lasting impact on the organization.

4. Mark Steenhuis

Mark Steenhuis was a dynamic playmaker and one of the most electrifying players to wear a Bandits jersey. With a career spanning 15 seasons in Buffalo (2002–2018), Steenhuis dazzled fans with his agility, creativity, and scoring ability. He holds the franchise record for most goals in a single game (7) and was a key offensive catalyst during his tenure. His versatility and knack for big moments made him a fan favorite and an integral part of the Bandits’ success during his era.

5. Steve Dietrich

A dominant presence between the pipes, Steve Dietrich was a game-changer for the Bandits during his time with the team (2002–2007). “Chugger,” as he was affectionately known, won the NLL Goaltender of the Year award in 2005, showcasing his elite shot-stopping ability and composure under pressure. Dietrich’s leadership and consistency in goal were pivotal to Buffalo’s deep playoff runs, and he remains one of the most respected goalies in league history. His induction into the NLL Hall of Fame in 2012 is a testament to his impact on the game.

These players have each left a profound mark on the Buffalo Bandits, shaping the team’s identity and thrilling fans with their talent and dedication. From pioneers like Tavares to modern stars like Smith, the Bandits’ legacy is a testament to their contributions.