The 5 Best Toronto Argonauts Players of All Time

The Toronto Argonauts, one of the oldest and most successful teams in Canadian football, boast a storied history filled with legendary players who have profoundly impacted the CFL. From Doug Flutie’s electrifying two seasons leading the Argos to consecutive Grey Cups to Michael “Pinball” Clemons’ unmatched versatility and lifelong dedication to the franchise, these athletes have defined excellence on and off the field. The list also includes Derrell Mitchell’s record-setting receiving prowess, Mike O’Shea’s defensive dominance and leadership, and Dick Shatto’s all-around brilliance during his era. Together, these players represent the pinnacle of Argonauts history and the enduring legacy of one of the league’s most celebrated teams.

Here’s a ranking of the top five Argonauts players, considering their impact, achievements, and lasting legacy:

1. Michael “Pinball” Clemons – RB (1989–2000)
Clemons epitomizes loyalty and versatility, contributing as a player, coach, and executive since 1989. During his playing career, he recorded:

• Second-most total touchdowns (85)
• Most punt return yards (6,025)
• Most receptions (682)

Clemons’ dynamic style and off-field contributions make him a cornerstone of Argos history.

2. Derrell Mitchell – WR (1997–2003, 2007)
As the franchise’s all-time leader in receiving touchdowns (74) and receiving yards (9,047), Mitchell was a consistent offensive force. He also ranks second in career receptions (609). Mitchell’s reliable hands and scoring ability cemented his place among the Argonauts’ elite.

3. Mike O’Shea – LB (1996–1999, 2001–2008)
A defensive stalwart, O’Shea won three Grey Cups as an Argonaut and earned recognition as the CFL’s Most Outstanding Canadian in 1999. Over 205 games with the Argos, he amassed 820 defensive tackles, 15 interceptions, and 25 sacks. O’Shea’s leadership extended to coaching, where he has continued to win Grey Cups with the Winnipeg Blue Bombers.

4. Dick Shatto – RB (1954–1965)
A franchise legend, Shatto still holds several Argos records, including:

• Most career touchdowns (91)
• Most rushing attempts (1,322)
• Most rushing yards (6,958)

His versatility as both a rusher and receiver made him a dominant player in his era and a lasting symbol of Argos excellence.

5. Doug Flutie – QB (1996–1997)
Although Flutie only played two seasons with the Argonauts, his impact was monumental. He completed 864 passes for 11,225 yards and 76 touchdowns, achieving a 64% completion rate. Flutie led the Argos to back-to-back Grey Cup victories in 1996 and 1997, earning MVP honors in both games. His dominance during these seasons solidified his legacy as one of the CFL’s greatest quarterbacks.

These players reflect the enduring legacy of the Toronto Argonauts, showcasing exceptional talent and a winning spirit that spans generations.