Ranking The Top 10 Greatest AFL Players of All Time

The Australian Football League (AFL) has seen countless remarkable players grace its fields, but some have stood out more than others due to their exceptional skill, leadership, and ability to change the course of a game. Here’s a look at the top 10 greatest AFL players of all time, who have set new standards of excellence in the sport.

1. Leigh Matthews
Leigh Matthews, often referred to as “Lethal,” is a legend in the AFL for his brutal strength, relentless pursuit of the ball, and fearless approach to the game. Matthews was a powerhouse in the midfield and later a dynamic small forward. Known for his toughness, he was not only feared by opponents but also admired for his resilience on the field. His strength even led to an infamous moment when he broke a point post at Windy Hill, an iconic testament to his physical dominance. Matthews’ ability to deliver under pressure made him an unforgettable figure in AFL history.

2. Wayne Carey
Wayne Carey, known as “The King,” is widely regarded as one of the best centre-half forwards ever to play the game. His combination of leadership, strength, skill, and finesse made him a complete player who could dictate the outcome of any game. Carey’s kicking ability, particularly his set shots, was almost unmissable, and he could win matches single-handedly. His dominance in contested marks and ability to create opportunities made him a nightmare for opposition teams. Even though his career was marred by controversy, Carey’s legacy as one of the AFL’s greatest players remains intact.

3. Gary Ablett Jr.
Gary Ablett Jr. was a freak of nature on the field, with the ability to turn any game in an instant. Known for his speed, strength, and extraordinary skill, Ablett was feared by opponents for his ability to play in almost any position and still excel. His versatility allowed him to dominate across the wing, in the midfield, and in attack. Whether playing for Geelong or later the Gold Coast Suns, Ablett’s ability to manipulate the game through sheer talent made him one of the most dangerous players in AFL history. His fearlessness and brilliance kept fans and coaches in awe.

4. Gary Ablett Sr.
Gary Ablett Sr., known for his sensational kicking and incredible consistency, is often considered the most talented player to ever play the game. His ability to kick goals from almost impossible angles and distances set him apart, and his remarkable performance in the 1993 season remains unmatched. Ablett’s astonishing speed, flawless judgment, and superb skills made him a devastating force on the field. He could carry an entire team, as seen in games where he would score multiple goals despite heavy opposition.

5. Ted Whitten
Ted Whitten, affectionately known as “Mr. Football,” is widely regarded as the greatest player in AFL history. His ability to lead, inspire, and perform at the highest level for so many years earned him the respect of fans and players alike. Whitten’s commitment and passion for the game were unparalleled, and he carried the Bulldogs to great heights during his illustrious career. His combination of skill, strength, and football IQ was ahead of its time, making him a true icon in the sport.

6. Chris Judd
Chris Judd was a dynamic midfielder whose influence on the game was profound. Known for his elite ball-winning ability and relentless work ethic, Judd was an exceptional contested ball player and a two-time Brownlow Medalist. His explosive speed and ability to change the course of a match made him a standout in the AFL. Judd’s leadership on and off the field helped lift Carlton and earned him a reputation as one of the best players of his era.

7. James Hird
James Hird’s elegant style and ability to perform in crucial moments made him one of the most skilled players to ever play the game. Known for his calm under pressure, Hird had the rare ability to make the toughest plays look effortless. His extraordinary vision and precision in front of goal were just a few of the many qualities that made him a standout player for Essendon. Hird’s determination and unselfish play made him a leader, and his performances in big moments helped define his career as one of AFL’s greats.

8. Tony Lockett
Tony Lockett is widely regarded as the greatest full forward in AFL history. His incredible goal-kicking ability, combined with his physicality, made him a nightmare for defenders. Lockett could score with remarkable accuracy from long distances, and his ability to take control of a game with his imposing presence was unmatched. Despite playing for a struggling St. Kilda side during his prime, Lockett’s sheer talent saw him become the highest goal-scorer in AFL history, solidifying his place as a true legend of the game.

9. Robert Harvey
Robert Harvey was one of the most consistent and enduring players in AFL history. His ability to accumulate possessions and dominate the midfield made him a key figure in St. Kilda’s resurgence in the late ’90s. Harvey’s remarkable fitness and ability to leave opponents trailing behind him set him apart. With two Brownlow Medals and numerous accolades, his career was a testament to hard work, dedication, and relentless pursuit of excellence.

10. Jason Dunstall
Jason Dunstall’s remarkable ability to lead and mark on the field made him one of the best full forwards of his time. With his strong hands and impeccable goal-kicking ability, Dunstall was a consistent threat in front of goal. He was a player who could perform in the big moments, delivering when Hawthorn needed it most. Even when his team struggled, Dunstall’s brilliance continued to shine, making him one of the game’s top players and a revered figure in AFL history.

These players represent the pinnacle of Australian football, and their incredible skills and achievements have shaped the AFL into what it is today. Each of them left a lasting impact on the game, and their legacies continue to inspire new generations of players and fans alike.